- Match toy size to your dog's mouth and paw size, too small is a choking risk, too large gets ignored
- High-drive breeds (working, herding, sporting) need more difficult enrichment than toy or companion breeds
- Flat-faced breeds (Pugs, Bulldogs, French Bulldogs, Boxers) often struggle physically with lick mats and slow feeders due to their facial structure, a genuine and commonly overlooked mismatch
- Start every dog, regardless of breed, at the easiest difficulty level and increase gradually
- Anxious or rescue dogs need calming enrichment (lick mats) before problem-solving enrichment (puzzle feeders)
The right enrichment toy matches three things: your dog's physical size, their breed's natural drive level, and their current confidence with enrichment generally. Get any of these wrong and the toy sits unused. Here's how to get it right the first time, including one common mismatch most guides don't mention.
Start with size, not preference
Size the toy to your dog's mouth and paw dimensions before anything else. A slow feeder or lick mat too small for a large breed gets flipped over and abandoned. One too large for a small or toy breed can be genuinely difficult to engage with.
General guide: small breeds (under 10kg) do well with compact lick mats and shallow slow feeders. Medium breeds (10-25kg) suit standard sizing. Large and giant breeds (25kg+) need wider surface area and deeper bowls to prevent tipping and hold a meaningful amount of food.
Match difficulty to breed drive, not just size
High-drive breeds, working, herding, and sporting breeds like Border Collies, German Shepherds, and Labradors, were bred for jobs requiring sustained mental focus. These dogs get bored quickly with easy enrichment. Start with a simple lick mat, but move to textured slow feeders and multi-step puzzle toys within a few weeks. An under-stimulated high-drive dog often shows it through destructive behaviour.
Companion and toy breeds, Cavaliers, Shih Tzus, generally have lower innate drive for problem-solving enrichment but still benefit from calming enrichment like lick mats.
Scent hounds, Beagles, Bassets, have an extremely strong nose-first drive. Snuffle mats and scatter feeding tend to outperform visual puzzle toys for this group.
Terriers were bred for hunting and digging, and often respond well to enrichment that lets them "dig" or manipulate an object physically, textured slow feeders with deeper channels tend to hold their interest longer than flat lick mats alone.
Flat-faced breeds need a different approach entirely
This is worth calling out specifically because it's genuinely overlooked: brachycephalic (flat-faced) breeds, Pugs, French Bulldogs, English Bulldogs, Boxers, Shih Tzus, often struggle physically with slow feeders and lick mats. Their shortened muzzle makes it harder to reach food in raised ridges, deep grooves, or recessed sections, sometimes to the point of frustration rather than enjoyment. This isn't a training issue, it's anatomical.
If you have a flat-faced breed, look for shallower, flatter textures rather than deep grooved mats, and watch your individual dog's reaction closely in the first few sessions. Some flat-faced dogs do fine with gentler textures; others do better with flat lick mats over deep bowl-style slow feeders specifically because they can access the surface more easily without straining.
Does age matter as much as breed?
Yes, and the two considerations work together rather than separately. A high-drive adult Border Collie and a Border Collie puppy need different starting points even though they're the same breed, the puppy should start at the easiest difficulty regardless of what an adult of the same breed could handle. Similarly, a senior dog of a historically high-drive breed may have scaled back their physical needs with age while still wanting the mental challenge, in which case a stationary puzzle feeder that doesn't require much movement can be a better fit than an active snuffle mat.
What if I have multiple pets with different needs?
This is common and worth planning for directly rather than buying one enrichment style and hoping it works for everyone. If you have a large high-drive dog and a small companion breed, or a dog and a cat, in the same household, it's usually easier to have separate, appropriately sized tools for each pet rather than one compromise option that's imperfect for both. Feeding and enrichment time can also become a resource-guarding trigger between pets, so separating tools by pet, in different areas of the house if needed, tends to work better than shared enrichment sessions.
For anxious or rescue dogs, start calm before you start hard
A rescue dog's enrichment needs are driven more by emotional state than breed or size. An anxious dog presented with a genuinely challenging puzzle toy in their first weeks in a new home is more likely to get frustrated and disengage than to enjoy the challenge. Start with a lick mat (passive, calming, near-zero failure rate), then a snuffle mat once settled, then slow feeders and puzzle toys as confidence builds.
How do I know if I chose wrong?
Signs a toy is too hard: your dog sniffs it once and doesn't return. Signs it's too easy: emptied in under 2 minutes with no real engagement. Signs it's the right fit: 10-20 minutes of active engagement, calmer afterward. Getting it wrong the first time is normal, adjust and try again.
How do I actually test whether a new enrichment toy is the right fit?
Give any new toy at least three separate sessions before deciding it's not working, a single session, especially the first one, isn't always representative of how your dog will engage once they understand what the toy is for. Keep the first three sessions at the easiest difficulty setting rather than adjusting between attempts, so you're comparing like for like. If engagement is still low or your dog seems frustrated rather than curious by session three, that's a genuine signal to change either the difficulty or the toy type altogether, rather than a sign to push harder with the same option.
Shop our full enrichment range →
Related: Are lick mats good for dogs? | Enrichment activities for rescue dogs